Friday, April 25, 2008

Sustainable Societies in History

A sustainable society is one that has survived for at least 300 years. It also has to have had some success in that it is economically sound, is socially stable and is culturally complex in that it has arts, religion, etc.

Hypothesis

There are many factors that influence why a society is successful or collapses. Many societies in the past have been successful for periods of time but then collapsed due to many different reasons, some that could’ve been prevented, and some that couldn’t have been prevented. I have come up with three main factors that influence if a society is sustainable. They are:

§ Defence of Society

§ Decision Making

§ Environmental and resource management

There are also many sub-factors that go under these headings and some that could fit under another heading as well.

Defence of society

This factor is important to a society being successful. Many societies in the past have collapsed because of this. The society has to be able to defend itself, not just from its neighbours but from its own people, since many societies have collapsed because of rebellions. An example of this is the Tang Dynasty. This dynasty collapsed because of rebellions by the people against the government which caused the dynasty to collapse.

However, not all societies can afford to have a strong military (the society might not have the money to fund it or not enough people to run it). If this is the case, then it is important for them to have good relations with other countries, particularly its neighbours and other influential countries around the world.

Australia

Although Australia’s military and defence system isn’t small, it wants to be sure that if something happens, it will have the support of others/ This is a major reason why Australia considers it to be important that it maintains good relationships with influential countries like the US and China. Although it has neglected Asia in the past because of its differences, it has now recognised that it is more important to have close relationships with countries like Indonesia over its relations with Britain which used to be considered more important than the need to maintain good relations with its close neighbours.

USA

The US has one of the biggest defence forces in the world. The technology that they use is also far more advanced than that of any other countries military. For 2007, the US government set aside US$439.3 billion for the military. This doesn’t include things like nuclear weapons research and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan which would cost many more billions of dollars. From this alone, it is clear that the US government views the defence of its country very highly and one of the more important factors in it being a sustainable society.

Bhutan

Bhutan is one of the smallest and poorest countries in the world. Its military is also very small and the country could be easily invaded by someone like India if they wanted to. However, Bhutan has been very close neighbours with India for many years now, thus decreasing the likelihood of it being invaded by them.

Decision making

For a society to be successful, the people of the society have to be flexible. This also includes the government. They and the people must be able to adapt to changing environments so that they can continue to survive. For some societies, this is very difficult for them, especially if the change conflicts with their culture.

Greenland Norse

The Greenland Norse didn’t eat fish because of their beliefs, even though it was probably their most abundant food source. Because they were inflexible in their culture, they died out because their other food sources ran out. On the other hand, the Inuit did eat fish and they have managed to survive for much longer than the Norse did.

Easter Island

The people of Easter Island cut down a lot of their trees to build huge statues that they considered to be important to their culture. By doing this, they used up a lot of their time and resources. By cutting down all the trees, they created a flow on effect which resulted in them starving to death because they ran out of food.

Mayans

The Mayans were a society whose actions were strongly influenced by their beliefs and culture. The Mayans had already deforested a lot of their land and then when they were suffering from decreased rainfall, they believed that this was a sign that their gods were unhappy so they responded to this by cutting down even more trees. This is another example of a society that collapsed because of poor decision making influenced by their beliefs and culture.

Climate Change

One of the key areas that current governments have to make decisions on is climate change. What the government decides to do about this issue will influence that country and others in the future. If a country takes a step forward and does something bold about this issue, then it could influence other countries to do the same. However, if the government does the wrong thing or does nothing, climate change has the capability to make that country/society no longer sustainable. Many governments around the world aren’t doing anything about this now because they are scared that the consequences of them trying to something about will do to their country. For a country to start tackling climate change, it has to first acknowledge that it is an issue that the country as a whole has to deal with if they want to be sustainable. One country that has taken this first step is New Zealand. As their Prime Minister Helen Clark said:

“Why shouldn’t New Zealand aim to be the first country which is truly sustainable – not by sacrificing our living standards, but by being smart and determined? I want New Zealand to be in the vanguard of making it happen – for our own sakes, and for the sake of our planet. I want sustainability to be central to New Zealand’s unique national identity.”

Iceland

With the rapidly decreasing stocks of fossil fuels and the realisation that it is causing global warming/climate change, the Icelandic government is aiming to become the first country in the world to be sustainable without the use of fossil fuels. Although many other countries are looking to do similar things, it will be much easier for Iceland to achieve this because they can take advantage of the abundance of geothermal and hydroelectric energy that it has. By using these two things to make energy, Iceland is using its location to its advantage. As it is located right on top of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, pipes are put into the ground where steam goes up and helps produce electricity and heating. Iceland is well on its way to achieving this target with 26.5 % of electricity production coming from geothermal energy, 73.4 % from hydroelectricity and just 0.1 % from fossil fuels in 2006. They have also begun to invest in hydrogen fuel technology, with the goal of getting rid of all cars powered by fossil fuels by 2050.

Government

What types of decisions a government makes will affect the whole society. A working government is important to this. What the government does has to be transparent so that everyone can see why those decisions were made. If there is transparency in the government, then it is quite likely that there will be no corruption. Also, the government has to make the right decisions for the people. If the government decides to be corrupt or they make decisions that make the people very upset, then they could start a rebellion. This in turn will be a set back for the society in terms of being sustainable because it is the cause of the collapses of many societies such as the Tang Dynasty.

Environmental and resource management

To survive, a society has to care and look after its environment because it effects how they live. There are many things that will effect the environment and all of these things need to be managed carefully. How a society manages its environment is influenced by a number of things such as location and cultural beliefs. Some of these are deforestation, waste management, over-use of resources and over-use of land.

Deforestation - Japan

Deforestation is one of the main factors affecting many societies today and in the past. One country that has managed its forests well in recent times is Japan. Although Japan has one of the worlds highest population density, almost 80% of its land is covered with forests. Japan has strict regulation concerning deforestation which helps it maintain its large amount land covered by forests. Before regulations were introduced though, Japan was on its way to cutting down all of its forests. Then in 1657, a large fire in Japan’s capital made the government realise how it’s over consumption of wood had badly affected the country in more ways than one. The continued deforestation had also caused increased erosion which in turn helped decrease crop yields which contributed to famines in Japan in the late 1600s. So the government introduced measures which have significantly decreased the amount of deforestation that happens in Japan and has grown back most of the forests that they had cut down. Although this step by the Japanese government has ensured that Japans forests are protected, it is still one of the world’s largest consumers of timber with all of its supply coming from other poorer countries like Brazil and Indonesia so in a sense, Japan is simply exporting all of its deforestation problems to poorer countries who need the money they make from cutting down forests.

Japan was quite lucky that it has been able to re-grow the forests that it had cut down. This is because that the land there is quite fertile due to the high levels of annual rainfall, previous volcanic eruptions and low level of soil salinity. In another country like Australia where there are high levels of soil salinity, low levels of annual rainfall and very little or no volcanic activity, it is very difficult to re-grow forests where they had previously existed. This is a sign that luck does play a role in whether or not a society is sustainable or not because some societies are located in fertile areas (eg. Japan) while some aren’t (eg. Australia).

Land Management - Iceland

In Iceland, one of the most concerning environmental issues for it is the overgrazing of land by sheep. The sheep eat all the vegetation on top, leaving the soil underneath exposed. This then resulted in the soil being carried or eroded away by strong winds, melting snow, water and glaciers. This then makes the soil unfertile because all the fertile soil has been taken away, making the land useless. It is possible that Iceland was deforested by overgrazing soon after it was settled. This has left much of the land bare except for a few low shrubs.

However, the Icelandic government has realised that this is a problem and has set up many forest restoration schemes. This has been quite successful with many recreational forests where tourists can go have been set up. They are also slowly growing more trees with more tall trees growing year after year.

Resource Management - Japan

The United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation estimates that Japan eats 30% of the world’s fresh fish, the most of any country in the world. As a part of their reafforestation program, the Japanese started to consume more fish because catching fish didn’t affect their efforts to regrow their forests. As a result of this, fish became one of their main food sources. Even though fish do reproduce, the Japanese are consuming them at a rate faster than the fish could reproduce. Japan hasn’t managed their fishing very well and now that they have over fished most of the areas adjacent to it, many fishermen are now illegally fishing in the zones of the countries such as Australia. This in turn is helping deplete the fish stocks from other areas of the world. In response to the issue of depleting fish stocks, Japan has cut its commercial fishing fleet by 25% and reduced the number of big factory boats.

Waste Management - Austria

Austria has one of the world’s best waste management plans in place at the moment. The main reason why they’ve done this is to protect the people and the environment while minimising harmful emissions and making the most of their resources. They have done this by raising the quality of waste disposal services and banning the dumping of organic waste. The Austrian government has said that the way the country disposes of its waste must not cause risks for future generations. This shows that Austria considers waste management as a crucial step in the country being sustainable in the future.

Conclusion

Many of the factors outlined above overlap each other; especially with decision making because what you do about each of the other factors is decided by the people (or government). The reason why we study previous societies is so that we can learn from their mistakes and further improve the things that others have done well so that we can be sustainable ourselves.

Bibliography

Armington, S. (2002), Bhutan, Lonely Planet Publications Pty Ltd, China

Anderson, A. (2007), Central Europe, Lonely Planet Publications Pty Ltd, China

Diamond, D. (2005), Collapse, Penguin Group, Great Britain

Parnell, F. (2007), Iceland, Lonely Planet Publications Pty Ltd, China

Richards, P.D. (1994), Asia Emerges, Thomas Nelson Australia, South Melbourne

Smith, D.B. (1995), Japan Since 1945, Macmillan Press Ltd, Malaysia

“Iceland” in World Book Encyclopaedia, (2007) Vol. 10, pp20-24

http://www.sustainableseattle.org/SustCommunity

http://www.theleftcoaster.com/archives/003431.php

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_protection_in_Japan

http://www.metla.fi/archive/forest/1995/07/msg00045.html

http://www.ecosys.or.jp/eco-japan/language/english.htm

http://www.saveamericasforests.org/JapansForests/Japansforests.htm

http://64.233.167.104/search?q=cache:JAslwBPLhEJ:www.euronetfor.eu/wpcontent/uploads/2006/12/euronefor_germany.pdf+germany%2B+forest+management&hl=en&ctclnk&cd=8&gl=au&client=firefox-a

http://www.bfn.de/fileadmin/MDB/documents/skript51.pdf

http://www.forestrytas.com.au/topics/2007/09/old-forests-newmanagement

http://www.esdtoolkit.org/discussion/default.htm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States

http://www.mfe.govt.nz/publications/climate/climate-changesolutions-overview-sep07/html/page5.html

http://www.grida.no/climate/ipcc_tar/wg2/059.htm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_Iceland

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhutan#Military_and_foreign_affairs

http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/4620/overfishing.htm

http://www.nationsencyclopedia.com/Asia-and-Oceania/JapanFISHING.html

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture%2C_forestry%2C_and_fishing_n_Japan#Fisheries

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2008/03/23wbhutan123.xml

http://umwelt.lebensministerium.at/article/articleview/49212/1/14403/

No comments: